28 Jan 2022

Women's health campaigner Vicky Phelan angered by absence of apology to Longford mum Lynsey Bennett

Women's health campaigner Vicky Phelan angered by absence of apology to Longford mum Lynsey Bennett

Vicky Phelan with Ryan Tubridy following her appearance on The Late Late Show last month prior to departing for Maryland

Following yesterday's High Court settlement of the case brought by brave Longford mum Lynsey Bennett, who is seriously ill with cancer, against the HSE, women's health campaign Vicky Phelan has taken to twitter this morning to vent her anger over why there was 'NO admission of liability and NO apology from either the HSE or the lab involved'. 

Also read: Brave Longford mum Lynsey Bennett to 'focus on her own fight to stay alive as long as she can' after settling her case against HSE

Ms Phelan, who is currently undergoing treatment with a new cancer drug in Maryland, United States, in a lengthy twitter thread commented,

"We do not know why no apology was made in Lynsey’s case but no apology was made in my case either until a few days after my case settled, nor was there an admission of liability. Yet, negligence was established in my case and I was awarded a settlement of €2.5 million."

She added, "Who are the HSE and the SCA (State Claims Agency) trying to fool by not admitting liability or apologising when such large amounts are being awarded?

"I would have far more respect for the HSE if they OWNED their mistakes and ADMITTED liability, particularly with cases that have been heard since the watershed Scally Report by Dr Gabriel Scally who found that the CervicalCheck programme was doomed to fail and that there were serious issues with QA and corporate governance with little to no oversight of the programme."

WATCH | Longford mum battling cancer for third time posts powerful and heartfelt video letter to An Taoiseach

Ms Phelan expressed concern that 'we are seeing a deeply disturbing narrative beginning to resurface DESPITE the fact that in ALL cases that have been heard, to date, for failures in cervical screening - negligence has been established & women have been compensated and we will ALL die as a result'.

She contined, "And still, women, like me and Lynsey Bennett and Ruth Morrissey - women who have had the audacity to air our dirty laundry in public and deign to sue the CervicalCheck programme, we have not been “wronged by the system. We have simply been unfortunate in not being one of those to have cancer detected early."

Ms Phelan wrote that 'in order to increase trust and confidence, it is incumbent on those involved in cervical screening, at every level, from the top to the bottom: - to acknowledge that harm was done - to accept that the programme DID fail women, and - to engage meaningfully with patient advocates'.

To continue reading this article for FREE,
please kindly register and/or log in.

Registration is absolutely 100% FREE and will help us personalise your experience on our sites. You can also sign up to our carefully curated newsletter(s) to keep up to date with your latest local news!

Register / Login

Buy the e-paper of the Donegal Democrat, Donegal People's Press, Donegal Post and Inish Times here for instant access to Donegal's premier news titles.

Keep up with the latest news from Donegal with our daily newsletter featuring the most important stories of the day delivered to your inbox every evening at 5pm.